Smoke Tube yes or no

I literally bought a pellet smoker so I wouldn't have to hassle with smoke tubes, lump charcoal, sticks, or any of that crap. So glad I did - and the OP's video just makes me realize that I made the right choice. I don't need/want a heavy smoke flavor - I want to taste my meat I prepped and a kiss of smoke - not a freak'n forest fire. But I understand of lot of ya'all love them smoke tubes. That's cool, you do you.
 
depends on what I am smoking. Cold smoke cheese. Yes. brisket or pork butt. No. Finishing burnt ends. Yes. Venison. No

Veggies Yes.

Just as you alluded to. The palate determines the degree of smoke. Since pellet smokers generate less smoke flavor some cooks need to be amped up with a tube. Some smokes are just fine.
 
I've owned my Pro 575 for a month. I did a sirloin tip roast but wasn't happy with the smoke ring. I bought two smoke tubes and today I did a test fire. I am really pleased with the amount of smoke they created. I did this because on Thursday I will smoke an 18 lb Brisket and wasn't sure which smoker I was going to use. I didn't want to screw up a $110.00 USDA Prime Brisket. Last Christmas the same Brisket was about $60.00 It's getting really hard to eat unhealthy. LOL
Something I learned with my smoke tube. I mix wood chips and pellets and let it burn for a few minutes. The correct position is important, and on the 575 don't put it on the right side as it effects the temp sensor. Don't put it on the left side as you smoke will go straight up the stack. Best position? in the middle and the meat above. I tried a pork neck yesterday and I cold smoked for 40 mins before lighting the Traeger. I read somewhere that cold meat absorbs smoke better. My tube was filled with 70% pellets and 30% maple fine chips (not wet). The neck was cooked at 225 for about 5-6 hours came out at 150f internal, rested for 30 mins and then I cut it into strips, coated with Maple brown sugar and fired up the traeger to 400f and cooked for 15 - 20 mins. Turned out like boneless pork ribs.
 
I’ve owned a smoke tube for years now and it’s still in the box. 🤷🏼‍♂️ I’m not chasing that offset heavy smoke profile though. I like the milder smoke profile. I have plenty of buddies however that run one or more at all times. It’s a personal preference deal.
 
Anyone put the smoke tubes on the upper rack? Or put meat on upper rack and tubes on the main rack?
 
Anyone put the smoke tubes on the upper rack? Or put meat on upper rack and tubes on the main rack?
I recommend utilizing the upper rack for the protein when cooking BBQ whenever possible. It just moves you further from the heat source. Also makes sense for the tube to be below if possible as the heat rises it will carry the smoke with it to the protein.
 
Anyone put the smoke tubes on the upper rack? Or put meat on upper rack and tubes on the main rack?

I agree with JPSBBQ - definitely cook on the top rack when you can, and keeping the smoke source below your protein will certainly give it more time to move around and infuse more efficiently. Keeping the smoke source above your proteins just gives it an easier exit through your chimney or rear vents.
 
Anyone put the smoke tubes on the upper rack? Or put meat on upper rack and tubes on the main rack?
I don’t unless I’m short on space. My 780 only has the main bottom grate and an upper small grate. I use a aftermarket grate and suspend it with some bricks. I put a drip/water pan on the main grate and i position my tubes one in the back and one on each side. Keeping the one on the side away from the ambient temp probe. I don’t put them directly under the meat it’ll cook it in that area and causes issues.
 
I've owned my Pro 575 for a month. I did a sirloin tip roast but wasn't happy with the smoke ring. I bought two smoke tubes and today I did a test fire. I am really pleased with the amount of smoke they created. I did this because on Thursday I will smoke an 18 lb Brisket and wasn't sure which smoker I was going to use. I didn't want to screw up a $110.00 USDA Prime Brisket. Last Christmas the same Brisket was about $60.00 It's getting really hard to eat unhealthy. LOL

A sirloin tip roast is not that big, so the cook time in only a few hours. If you like a distinct smoke ring, then using a smoke tube might help.

A 18# packer brisket will take a very long time to cook. Even if you do not use a smoke tube, you should develop a nice smoke ring as the brisket will be in the smoke for many hours.
 
Back
Top