I cook my ribs a little differently, but with the same result: perfect for my tastes and comes out almost exactly the same each time. And it is not just ribs. After about 3 or 4 attempts I nailed down how to do briskets, and now it comes out perfect for me every single time. Compared to hot and fast, low and slow BBQ can be a complicated process, but the Traeger makes it so easy.
Granted that it may not be as good as an offset smoker or other ones, it is pretty close. The benefit of not have to constantly tend a fire makes it more than worthwhile. If I am having company, I can prepare other things while the Traeger is cooking.