You've Gotta Love a Butt

RayClem

Well-known member
Joined
May 4, 2022
Messages
1,401
Media
38
Reaction score
1,273
Location
Chicago suburbs
Grill
Ironwood 885, Char-Griller Flat Iron Premium griddle, InkBird Sous Vide
I am very new to pellet smokers. I have primarily used gas grills for many years. But they say you are never too old to learn new tricks, so I got an Ironwood 885. I am glad I did.

I grew up in Virginia where peanut fed hogs are world famous. I now live in Chicagoland. Chicago was once considered the "hog butcher of the world" a title bestowed upon the city by the poet Carl Sandburg. The stockyards are no more, but pork of all kinds is still found in the Windy City. Thus, I am a big fan of barbecued pork.

After a successful cook of some pork tenderloins, I thought I would set my sights on something a little larger. So it was off to the local Meijer store. While looking through the meat chillers, I came across some Pork Shoulder Butts that were marked 1/2 price as they are approaching the sell by date. I picked up one slightly more than 9# for $1.49 per pound, not bad in these days of inflated prices. Here is my story.

I trimmed off any lose meat and trimmed the fat cap down to a thin layer. I don't need the extra fat as I am fat enough.

I gave the butt a good slap and slathered it with Mustard Girl Horseradish Mustard. I am not a fan of plain yellow mustard, so I did not have any in the cupboard. I seasoned the butt with a good coating of Chicago Chop seasoning from The Spice Lab and All American Seasoning & Rub from Pork Barrel BBQ. That added both flavor and color. The meat went back into the refrigerator overnight.

I preheated the grill to 250 degrees F using Expert Grill Sweet Blend pellets from Walmart. I had used Pit Boss Apple Blend for the tenderloins, so I wanted to try something different. I liked the Sweet Blend well enough to add another bag to my shopping list.

I added a mixture of apple cider vinegar and apple juice to a tray placed on the bottom rack of the Ironwood to keep the meat moist. I am really glad I used the tray as there was quite a mess left in the tray after the cook. I would not have wanted to clean that mess out of the grill. Unfortunately, I forgot to cover the tray with aluminum foil, so I did have some cleanup work to do.

The meat went on the top shelf. I checked it every couple of hours, spritzing it with a mixture of apple cider vinegar and apple juice. I turned the meat 180 degrees after four hours. After six hours of smoking, the internal temp was about 155 degrees and the bark looked good. I monitored the cook using both the Traeger probe and another thermometer from Tudoccy which seems to be more accurate than the one from Traeger.




RWC_Butt.jpg




I wanted the cook to finish about 4:00 pm so I could pull it for an early supper. I would have liked the meat to remain unwrapped for the full cook to develop more smoke flavor and an even better bark, but I was afraid that it might not come up to full temperature so I decided to place the meat on a rack in an aluminum pan tightly wrapped with aluminum foil. I added a mixture of 1/3 apple cider vinegar, 1/3 apple juice, and 1/3 Kinder's Organic Mild BBQ Sauce. Initially, I mixed the ACV and Kinder's, but that was way too sour. The apple juice diluted the vinegar and added some sweetness to produce a more balanced flavor.

The pork when back into the Ironwood for another 3 1/2 hours until it was probe tender. While that was cooking, I soaked a couple of ears of corn on the cob and placed them in the smoker along with the meat.

I removed the meat from the smoker and allowed it to cool slightly. When I removed the aluminum foil, I found the aluminum pan was nearly full of juices from the meat along with the marinade I had added at the start. The bone came out of the butt easily and the meat was not difficult to pull using meat claws. There was a nice smoke ring under the bark. The bark itself was a little salty, but the meat inside was tender, flavorful and juicy. After pulling the pork, I poured all of that liquid over top the meat,

When we sat down to eat, I placed a bottle of Sweet Baby Ray's original BBQ sauce on the table. That sauce is ubiquitous in the Chicago area. However, we never opened the bottle. The meat was smoky, sweet, and spicy without the need for additional sauce.

Since it is just my wife and I, we should get a total of ten meals from the pulled pork. That will be some good eating.

I will probably try either some St Louis style ribs, rib tips or a full slab of spare rib sometime this summer. In many places rib tips are considered scrap meat removed in the trimming of spare ribs to get St Louis style ribs. In the Chicago area, BBQ rib tips are considered a delicacy.
 
A follow up question. I have cooked beef roasts in the oven or in a slow cooker, but I have never tried one on the grill. What cut of beef would you recommend that I try first as venture into that phase of smoking. I tried the pork butt because people said it was nearly impossible to mess up.

I know briskets are commonly smoked, but is that the best cut for a relative beginner? Also, I understand that brisket can be purchased as a whole packer cut or the flat and point cuts? Which version would be best for starting out?

Are there other cuts that you would recommend? For example, I considered picking up a chuck roast as it seemed to have enough fat to keep the meat moist through hours on the smoker. What about a tri-tip roast? I am a member of Costco, so I can purchase at the one nearby.
 
Last edited:
Chuck roasts are good to do. One of our favorites is a tri tip. I am fortunate that my local meat shop ages them and keeps them in stock. For the price they are one of my favorites. I see them from time to time at Sams etc. but they are always small and usually packed in seasoning/marinate. The ones I get are aged and about like a brisket. They a the fat still on them and I trim them to my liking. Only 7.00 per pound here also. We smoke until 125 and then sear.
 
I did tri tip for the first beef cook. Fairly easy cook
 
Excellent write up. All that was missing was a dram of single malt scotch. Cheers!
 
Just to follow up, I stopped by the meat counter of my local Meijer store yesterday morning. They had chuck eye roasts on sale Buy One Get One 1/2 off, so I could not resist, especially after the recommendations from @Slimpicker and @midwest. Thanks guys!

I seasoned the meat and dry brined it for a couple of hours. Then I marinated it in the fridge overnight. It came out of the fridge at 5:30 this morning. I fired up both the gas grill and the Ironwood at 6:00. I seared the two slabs of meat at 450 F degrees on the gas grill for 4 minutes per side. Then on to the Traeger at 225 F at 6:30 am.

I am using a combination of Pit Boss charcoal blend pellets and Mesquite pellets in the hopper and in two smoke tube which are a recent addition. An hour into the cook smoke is just rolling out the back of the Ironwood. I do not know how much of the smoke is due to the smoke tubes and how much is due to the charcoal blend pellets, but the smoke is much thicker than I have seen from wood pellets alone without the tubes. Who says Traegers can't produce smoke?

I plan to smoke the chuck to an internal temp of 160 F and then wrap it to finish off somewhere between 200-205F to make sure it is tender. The smaller roast will probably get to the higher temp, so I will pull that one. I plan to slice the larger roast.

This afternoon, I will add a sweet potato and a basket of squash and zucchini to the smoker. That should make a wonderful dinner.
 
Back
Top