Beef Brothers of Smoke! - Please advise..

daddyo

New member
Joined
Jun 18, 2020
Messages
12
Reaction score
6
Location
Hoosier State
Grill
Pro 22
I am cooking a whole beef tenderloin for Father's Day. I have two first time fathers. My son and son-in-law. A beautiful new born boy and girl. Thank you! We are blessed.

To celebrate, Dad springs for a whole beef tenderloin. I'm a bit concerned about the difference in thickness between the tail and head end. Looking for comments on may plan.

- Trim the tail. I'll trim off perhaps a pound of the thinnest of the tail for another day. My wife and I love the one piece tails. Perfect for two.
- Dry well, rub well with olive oil and season with Spiceology Salt, Pepper, Garlic.
- I'm using hickory pellets. Kind of settled in on that for my smoked meals. Family likes.
- With loin at room temp and seasoned, run on smoke for an hour. (175-180) I tent my exhaust pipe - stuff a towel in it - on smoke to hold the barrel full. (Windy here...)
- Remove. Crank up the Traeger full. 385-395 on mine.
- Cook the thick end to 130 degrees. Remove. Rest. My crew likes medium to medium well. (Personally, I'll take the mid-rare if there is one.)
- Hoping with the taper on the loin to have cuts from medium to medium well.

Doing twice bakes for the sides and a chimichurri dress.

I've cooked whole loins before, but never without a sear. Alternatively, I could build a fire on my egg and cook like a caveman.
 
If it was me preparing that cook, I’d definitely tie that tenderloin so that it is a uniform size and will cook evenly.
056446BB-73BC-44C4-8E0F-D3200FF52719.jpeg
 
Forgot to mention, I wouldn’t cook that beautiful piece of meat to medium well (dried out) either..
I would pull it at an IT of 120, tent and rest for 30 minutes (that should bring the IT to 125-130), slice it, and sear the individual slices in a hot cast iron skillet to the desired doneness. That way, your aren’t cooking the entire tenderloin to med-well.
My wife likes dried out, ruined meat, and that’s the way I prepare tenderloin, rib roast, etc, so as not to ruin the entire cut of meat.
I can have mine med-rare, and she can have hers dried out…😬
 

Latest Discussions

Back
Top